Finding the Right Doctor: A Comprehensive Guide
- Melissa Nichols
- Aug 17
- 5 min read
Updated: Sep 1
The Importance of a Primary Care Doctor
I had my first health scare in my early 30s. I herniated a disc in my back, which caused severe sciatica. I wasn't prepared. I had always been healthy and only saw a gynecologist for routine exams. She was also my primary care provider. I relied on her for referrals, which wasn't ideal for sciatica. I went from one doctor to another, researching online, but it was excruciating to sit for too long. My condition worsened as I waited to see a specialist. Even then, I had to wait longer to get the treatment I needed, which meant an extended period on medication first. Lesson learned. I will never be unprepared again, and this is how I manage it.
1. Finding a Doctor
As a general rule, I start with the hospital where I would want to be treated if I had a significant health condition. The only exception would be for cancer, where a specialized cancer hospital may be a better option. Most doctors are affiliated with a specific hospital. If you need a specialist and aren't already their patient, you will have to wait a while to get in on your own. Having your primary care doctor send a referral can expedite this process. This is key. They will refer you to someone in their network, so find the network or hospital that you believe offers the best quality of care.
One thing to consider is that some hospitals may only offer treatment options available at their facility. So, do your research. Suppose you're at a hospital in a smaller city. They may not provide you with a comprehensive overview of all treatments available for your condition, which might only be accessible elsewhere. I experienced this twice with family members who were treated in my hometown and not given the options that I knew were available in New York City. It should be your choice to travel elsewhere for a different treatment.
Techniques to Find a Primary Care Physician
Here are some techniques to find a primary care physician:
Start by using trusted platforms such as RateMDs.com or Vitals.com to read patient reviews of doctors, clinics, and specialists in your area—it's free. It helps you assess communication styles and bedside manner.
Go to your insurance website and search for all the physicians who accept your insurance at the hospital of your choice. Other search criteria are available, such as doctors who are accepting new patients, gender (if that is of interest), conditions they treat, and even the university they studied at.
2. Preparing for Your Visit with a Doctor
Preparation is key to a successful doctor visit. Here are some steps to take:
Be Proactive When Booking: Let the scheduler know if you have multiple concerns or specific issues. This can help them assign the appropriate appointment length so you don't feel rushed.
Make a Complete Prep Kit: Create a list of current medications, including doses and supplements. I use an app called Suppco that shows a picture of my supplement with its ingredients. It summarizes everything you are taking into one list of ingredients. This is a great way to know if you are taking too much of something. It also assigns a score to the brand you are taking to ensure you are only taking quality supplements.
Gather Your Medical History: Bring paper copies or printouts of your medical history, any recent diagnoses, and test results. Don’t assume your doctor already has everything, even if you send it electronically. See the medical history template in the Resources section of my website.
Prepare a Clear, Prioritized List: Create a list of symptoms, concerns, and questions, ranked by urgency.
Practice Your Opening: Consider crafting a short opening statement that conveys your primary concern while acknowledging time constraints. This sets a focused tone for the visit.
Bring Support If Needed: A trusted person can listen, take notes, and help prompt you if you forget something. This is especially helpful in stressful or complex visits.
Take Notes or Record on Your Phone (With Permission): Keeping a record of the advice, next steps, or terminology used can help later. You could also ask if it's okay to record audio for later review.
Do Your Homework: Research your symptoms using credible sources—NIH, CDC, or other trusted medical sites—so you can ask informed questions or confirm your understanding.
3. Navigating the Doctor Visit Efficiently
During your visit, efficiency is crucial. Here are some tips to navigate the appointment:
Keep Focused and Concise: Stick to the most critical issues first. Doctors often have limited time, so managing your agenda wisely matters.
Ask Clear, Specific Questions: If you're unsure or want alternative perspectives, try asking, "Is there another possible explanation?" or "What else could this be?" If prescribed a medication, ask if there are diet or lifestyle alternatives you could try first, and always ask about side effects.
Voice Disagreement Respectfully: Avoid confrontation by phrasing concerns in a collaborative way. For example: "Could we explore other options?"
Inquire About Monitoring Conditions: If you have a condition that your physician wants to monitor over time, ask for more details about what they are looking for and when treatment would be necessary. This will allow you to prepare and possibly make changes to your diet or lifestyle.
4. If Your Doctor Isn't a Good Fit
Not every doctor will be the right fit for you. Here’s how to recognize when it’s time to find a new one:
Pay Attention to Your Feelings: If you feel dismissed or misunderstood, particularly as a woman or from a marginalized group, you may experience invalidation or gaslighting in medical settings. I have always used naturopathic physicians and functional medicine doctors alongside my conventional doctors. If your conventional doctors treat these other physicians as if they aren't relevant, you may want to look elsewhere.
Trust Your Gut: If something doesn't feel right with the diagnosis, the interaction, or the care, consider seeking a second opinion or switching doctors.
Evaluate Your Connection: Do you feel like you can trust this person? Do they align with your values?
Assess Communication: Does your doctor explain health issues in detail and discuss the side effects of medications?
Explore Treatment Options: Doctors may give you only the options for treatment available at their hospital. Ask if there are options that are only available in other hospitals.
Be Cautious of One-Sided Information: If they emphasize the benefits of a drug or procedure without mentioning side effects, be wary. All drugs have side effects, and some may not occur until many years later.
5. Health Insurance
How do you appeal a health insurance denial or manage a medical bill? If you need help navigating complex care or insurance issues, look into patient advocacy services through resources like the Patient Advocate Foundation or the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) listings of patient advocates by state or condition.
6. Managing a Health Condition
Consider joining online patient communities for peer recommendations and support, such as PatientsLikeMe and HealthUnlocked. These platforms allow you to compare experiences, track symptoms, and connect with others facing similar health journeys. Roon.com is another resource where you can ask questions that are answered by physicians.
Helpful Apps & Websites for Self-Advocacy
Here are tools you can leverage to support your advocacy journey:
Tool / Website | How It Helps |
Research doctors' reviews and communication styles | |
Reviews on Physicians | |
Track symptoms, compare treatments, and learn from patient experiences | |
Join condition-specific communities, get peer support | |
Patient Advocate Foundation / State-Based Advocates | Find help with navigating billing, insurance, or system navigation |
Doctors answer health questions |
In Summary
Advocating for yourself with your doctor doesn't require confrontation. It's built on preparation, clarity, and persistence. By choosing the right doctor, arriving well-prepared, communicating effectively, leveraging helpful digital tools, and knowing when to move on, you command the conversation and shape your care more confidently.
Comments